Mikku and Sons Roofing logo, featuring a roof illustration on a transparent background 623-465-1068

DIY vs. Professional Roof Repairs: What You Need to Know

Date: August 28, 2024

Your roof is more than just a part of your home; it's your first line of defense against the elements. When something goes wrong up there, it can be a stressful situation.

You might notice a leak after a heavy rain, see a few shingles out of place, or feel uneasy about the overall condition of your roof. The big question that often comes up is: Should you grab your tools and tackle the repair yourself, or should you call in a professional?

On one hand, DIY repairs can save you money and give you a sense of accomplishment. On the other hand, you might worry about the potential risks—like the safety concerns of working on a roof or the possibility of making a mistake that could lead to bigger problems down the road. What do you need to know between DIY vs. Professional roof repairs?

The Scope of Roof Repairs

Roof repairs can range from simple fixes, like replacing a few missing shingles, to more extensive work, such as addressing structural damage. The key is to assess the situation carefully, understanding both the visible problems and any underlying issues that may not be immediately obvious.

This will help you avoid turning a minor issue into a major headache and ensure that your roof remains in good condition for the long haul.

1. Types of Roof Repairs: Minor vs. Major

Roof issues can be broken down into two main categories: minor repairs and major repairs.

Minor repairs might involve something as straightforward as fixing a small leak or replacing a handful of shingles. These are tasks that, with the right tools and a bit of know-how, you might be able to handle on your own.

Major repairs, on the other hand, involve more significant issues that often require specialized skills and equipment. These could include repairing structural damage, addressing large areas of the roof, or fixing problems that have developed over time due to neglect or severe weather.

2. Common DIY Repairs

Some roof repairs are straightforward enough that you might feel confident tackling them yourself. These typically involve smaller, less complicated tasks where the risk is low and the required tools are basic.

Fixing a small leak, replacing a few damaged shingles, or cleaning out gutters are examples of DIY-friendly repairs that many homeowners manage on their own.

However, it’s crucial to recognize your limits. Even seemingly simple repairs can escalate into bigger problems if not done correctly.

3. Situations Requiring Professional Attention

There are times when roof repairs are beyond what a typical homeowner should attempt. These situations often involve complex or dangerous tasks, such as repairing extensive water damage, fixing structural issues, or working on a steep roof.

In these cases, the expertise of a professional is invaluable, not just for the quality of the work but also for your safety. Calling in a professional doesn’t just mean the job will be done correctly; it also gives you peace of mind.

Pros of DIY Roof Repairs

Taking on a DIY roof repair can be an appealing option, especially if you're someone who enjoys tackling home improvement projects. There's a certain satisfaction that comes with fixing something yourself, and when it comes to your roof, the potential cost savings can be significant.

However, beyond the financial aspect, there are several other benefits to consider when you decide to go the DIY route.

1. Cost Savings

By handling the repairs yourself, you eliminate the cost of labor, which can be a substantial part of any repair bill. If the problem is minor, such as a few missing shingles or a small leak, the materials needed might be inexpensive, making the repair much more affordable than hiring a professional.

2. Immediate Action

DIY repairs give you the flexibility to tackle issues as soon as they arise without waiting for a contractor to become available. This can be particularly beneficial in preventing a small issue from becoming a larger one, as you can take immediate action to stop leaks or replace damaged materials before they lead to more serious problems.

3. Learning Experience

Every DIY project is an opportunity to learn new skills, and roof repairs are no different. By taking the time to research, plan, and execute the repair, you can gain valuable knowledge about your home’s structure and how to maintain it.

4. Personal Satisfaction

There’s a sense of accomplishment that comes from fixing something with your own hands. Completing a roof repair on your own can be incredibly rewarding, especially when you see the results of your hard work.

5. Control Over the Process

When you choose to do your own roof repairs, you have complete control over the process. This means you can work at your own pace, choose the materials you prefer, and ensure that the job is done to your standards.

Benefits of Hiring Professional Roofers

When it comes to roof repairs, bringing in a professional can offer you a level of security and peace of mind that’s hard to achieve with a DIY approach. While the initial cost might be higher, the advantages of hiring a skilled roofer often far outweigh the expense.

1. Expertise and Experience

Professional roofers have years of training and hands-on experience that enable them to quickly diagnose and repair a wide range of roofing issues. Their expertise allows them to identify not just the obvious problems but also any underlying issues that could lead to future damage if left unaddressed. 

2. Safety

Safety is a top priority for professional roofers. They are equipped with the proper tools, safety gear, and techniques to handle repairs without risking injury.

Working on a roof involves inherent dangers, such as heights, slippery surfaces, and the potential for accidents.  

3. Warranties and Guarantees

One of the key benefits of hiring a professional roofer is the warranty or guarantee that often comes with their work. This means that if anything goes wrong after the repair, the roofer will return to fix it at no additional cost.

Warranties provide an added layer of protection for your investment, giving you confidence that the repair will hold up over time.

Drawbacks of Professional Roof Repairs

While hiring a professional roofer comes with many advantages, it's important to consider the potential downsides as well. The decision to bring in a pro should be weighed carefully, especially when factoring in costs, scheduling, and the overall experience. 

1. Higher Costs

Professional repairs can be expensive, especially when compared to the DIY route. Labor costs, along with the price of materials, can add up quickly, and if the damage is extensive, the bill could be quite substantial.

2. Scheduling Delays

Depending on the season and the demand for roofing services in your area, you might have to wait days or even weeks for a contractor to become available. During this time, the problem with your roof could worsen, especially if it's exposed to harsh weather conditions.

This delay can be frustrating, particularly if you're eager to get the repair done quickly.

3. Potential for Overcharging

Unfortunately, not all roofing contractors operate with transparency. There’s a risk of being overcharged for services, especially if you’re not familiar with standard roofing costs or the specific needs of your repair.

Some contractors might recommend more extensive repairs than necessary or use higher-priced materials than what’s required. 

When to Choose DIY

Deciding to tackle a roof repair yourself can be a smart move in certain situations. If you're confident in your abilities and the problem at hand is relatively simple, a DIY approach can save you money and give you the satisfaction of fixing the issue on your own.

However, it's important to recognize when DIY is appropriate and when it's better to leave the job to a professional. 

1. Small, Simple Repairs

DIY is often a good choice for small, straightforward repairs that don’t require specialized knowledge or equipment. For example, if you’re dealing with a few missing or damaged shingles, fixing a minor leak, or cleaning out gutters, these tasks are usually within the reach of most homeowners.

These types of repairs are generally low-risk and don’t involve structural components of the roof, making them ideal for DIY efforts.

2. Budget Constraints

If you're on a tight budget, DIY repairs can be an attractive option. By handling the repair yourself, you avoid the labor costs associated with hiring a professional, which can be significant.

For minor repairs, the cost of materials is often minimal, making DIY a cost-effective solution. However, it's essential to weigh the potential savings against the risks—especially if you're not entirely confident in your ability to complete the repair correctly.

3. Personal Skill Level

Your own experience and comfort level with home improvement projects are key factors in deciding whether to take on a roof repair yourself. If you have a background in construction, have successfully completed similar projects in the past, a DIY repair might be a good fit.

On the other hand, if you're unsure about your skills or the repair seems more complex than expected, it might be better to reconsider.

4. Immediate Need

Sometimes, you might need to address a roof problem immediately, and waiting for a professional isn’t an option. In cases where a small repair can prevent further damage—such as patching a minor leak before a storm—doing it yourself can be a practical solution.

This immediate action can help protect your home from more extensive damage, buying you time until you can arrange for a professional inspection if needed.

When to Hire a Professional

While there are situations where DIY roof repairs can be practical, there are times when hiring a professional is the wiser choice. Roof repairs can range from relatively simple fixes to complex tasks that require specialized skills, tools, and knowledge. 

1. Complex or Large-Scale Repairs

If the damage to your roof is extensive or involves structural components, it's time to call in a professional. Complex issues such as significant water damage, roof sagging, or large areas of missing shingles require more than just a quick patch-up.

Professionals have the training and experience needed to assess the full extent of the damage and implement the appropriate repairs. Attempting to handle these types of repairs on your own can lead to costly mistakes and even more significant problems down the road.

2. Safety Concerns

Roofing work inherently involves risks, especially if your roof is steep, high, or difficult to access. If the repair requires working at heights, using specialized equipment, or dealing with hazardous materials, hiring a professional is the safest option.

Roofing professionals are trained to handle these risks with the proper safety gear and techniques, minimizing the chances of injury. Your safety is paramount, and in situations where there’s a significant risk, it’s always better to err on the side of caution.

3. Peace of Mind

When you hire a professional roofer, you gain peace of mind knowing that the job will be done correctly. Professionals bring years of experience to the table, which means they can often spot issues that might go unnoticed by the untrained eye.

They also use high-quality materials and adhere to industry standards, ensuring that your roof repair is durable and effective. This level of expertise and attention to detail provides assurance that your roof will continue to protect your home for years to come.

4. Time Efficiency

Roof repairs can be time-consuming, especially if you’re not experienced in the work. Professionals, on the other hand, can complete repairs much more quickly and efficiently.

They have the right tools, materials, and expertise to get the job done in a fraction of the time it might take you. This efficiency not only minimizes disruption to your daily life but also ensures that your home is protected from the elements as quickly as possible.

Are Converse Good for Walking on Roofs?

When it comes to roof repairs, the decision between DIY and hiring a professional ultimately comes down to your specific situation. While DIY can be rewarding and cost-effective for small, manageable tasks, professional help is often the safer and more reliable option for larger or more complex repairs.

Speaking of safety, if you’re considering a DIY roof repair, you might wonder about the best footwear for the job. While Converse shoes are popular for their style and comfort, they aren’t designed for the risks involved in roofing.

Proper footwear with good grip and ankle support is crucial when working on a roof, as it can help prevent slips and falls. Choosing the right gear, including footwear, is just one of the many factors that highlight why professional roofers are often the safer choice. 

About Mikku & Sons
Mikku and Sons red repair track with its logo painted on its side- roofing company track wraps
Our roofing company was founded in 2001 by Michael Riutta, who is still part of the ownership and management team. Between Michael, his two sons and co-owners, Devin and Joshua, and our crew members, we have many years of experience to handle any type of roof repair or roof installation solutions you may need.
crossmenu